Frequently asked questions
What is the rule of 55, and does it let me retire before 59 and a half?
The rule of 55 lets you withdraw from your current employer's 401(k) penalty-free if you leave that job in or after the year you turn 55. It doesn't help if you leave earlier, and it doesn't apply to IRAs. That's exactly the gap Matt and Megan hit: leaving at 52 meant the rule of 55 wasn't available, which is why the taxable brokerage account and phased consulting income had to do the bridging instead.
What's considered a good probability of success for a retirement plan?
We look for 80% or higher on a Monte Carlo simulation. Above that threshold, a bad market usually means trimming spending for a year or two, not abandoning the plan. Below it, the plan is more fragile than the balance sheet suggests, which is exactly what a 62% score was telling Matt and Megan before we restructured anything.
How much of my retirement savings should be in Roth accounts?
There's no universal percentage. It depends on your current tax bracket, expected retirement income, and how much flexibility you want later. What matters more than a target ratio is having enough in Roth and taxable accounts to give you options: money you can spend without triggering a tax bill or a penalty in the years before 59 and a half. An asset location strategy, where your accounts are organized by when you'll actually need the money, is how we typically map that out with clients.
Can I do a mega backdoor Roth if I'm not sure my company offers it?
Many executives don't know their plan includes it, Matt didn't. It requires your 401(k) plan to allow after-tax contributions beyond the standard deferral limit and in-plan Roth conversions or in-service withdrawals. The only way to know is to check your plan documents or ask your HR or benefits team directly, since not every employer plan supports it.
Do Roth conversions push me into a higher tax bracket?
They can, which is exactly why timing matters. We convert deliberately, filling a target bracket (32% in this case) rather than converting everything at once. Low-income years, like Matt's two years off between corporate work and consulting, are when a larger conversion costs the least.
What if I don't have consulting income to bridge the gap between early retirement and 59 and a half?
Consulting income wasn't required, it just reduced how hard the taxable account had to work. The same structure holds without it: build enough in Roth and taxable accounts before you stop earning to cover your bridge years, and use any low-income window you do have for conversions. Every hybrid retirement plan we build starts with mapping that bridge to the client's actual numbers, which is exactly the kind of conversation we have at Tailored Wealth on a Free Wealth Strategy Call.
