College Planning

The College Sticker Price Is a Lie: How High Earners Pay for College Without Derailing Retirement

Written By: Dan Pascone
TL;DR: The sticker price is almost never what you pay. The real risk for high earners isn't tuition, it's letting one unplanned six-figure decision cost you years of your own retirement.
- Your real number depends on each school's business model, not the headline. Run the net price calculator and call financial aid.
- Fund in order: shrink the bill first, spend earmarked savings, redirect freed-up cash flow, then borrow only the delta.
- Translate any loan into a real monthly payment before anyone signs.
We sat down with Shanna Due, founder of Due Financial, who does one thing all day: help families get the college experience they actually want for the least amount of money. Here's the playbook from that conversation, translated for a household with real income and a real retirement on the line.

The sticker price is a lie
(why the big number isn't your number)

Every school publishes a cost of attendance. That's the big number, and it has crossed $100,000 a year at some universities. Very few students actually pay it.
That gap is where families make their biggest mistake. About 5 million students head off to college each year, and too many start by opening the internet and picking any school they want, sticker price and all. As Shanna puts it, we don't let our kids pick any car off the internet, because they'll come back with a Lamborghini. College deserves the same discipline. This is a house-sized decision, not a Honda Civic.
The flip side is just as costly: families rule out a great school because of sticker shock, when that school may be the one most likely to compete for your student with aid. The headline number tells you almost nothing about your number.

Colleges are businesses. Learn to decode the model.

Most nonprofit universities are still businesses, and each one runs a different model. The sooner you understand that a school is a business and you are the informed consumer, the better your outcome. The pricing is opaque, and some of it is opaque by design.
Two things every family should do:

1. Read the net price calculator.

  • Every school that takes federal funding is required to publish one on its website. Some are updated yearly and excellent. Others use a generic version. Use it as a starting estimate, not gospel.

2. Call the financial aid and admissions offices directly.

  • Ask two plain questions: How do you treat merit aid (scholarships based on achievement, not need)? What need-based aid do you offer? Many schools publish this, but if they don't, ask.

The reason this matters is that merit and need are treated completely differently school to school. Some of the most prestigious schools offer no merit aid at all. They can be very generous on need, but if you don't have financial need, they won't discount the price. So if your finances are tight, borrowing six figures for a degree you could earn at many schools is hard to justify. As Shanna notes, you don't need an Ivy League name to go teach.
The exception is a major that requires a specific, accredited program. Architecture is the clean example: only so many schools are certified, so the school genuinely matters. For most majors, you can get a strong education almost anywhere and do just fine. Decide which situation you're in before you price anything.

Shanna's three-legged table: what you actually want from college

Before the money conversation, get clear on what the experience is worth to your family. Picture a table. On top, you put everything you want out of college: community, a specific skill, critical thinking, self-discovery, an alumni network, internship experience. Three legs hold that table up:

1. Academic fit.

  • Does it have the major? Will it actually advance the career? Do they teach the way your student learns?

2. Social fit.

  • Big or small, urban or rural, heavy Greek life or not, big sports or not.

3. Financial fit.

  • What's the real cost to parents, grandparents, and the student, especially over the long term?

Most families arrive knowing roughly what kind of school they want. Almost none understand the financial leg. That's the one that quietly reshapes the next decade of your life, so it deserves the most work.

The funding order most parents skip past

Step
Source
What to know
Shrink the bill first
AP, dual enrollment, CLEP, merit scholarships
Credits and merit awards are your biggest lever. One student earned $30,000 over four years.
Spend earmarked savings
529 plans, taxable brokerage
Tax-advantaged money built for this. A 529 can do more than tuition.
Consider Roth principal
Roth IRA contributions
Contributions come out penalty-free. Can beat borrowing if the plan supports it.
Add student income
Summer and part-time work
Modest, but builds ownership and covers real costs.
Redirect freed-up cash flow
Money no longer spent on the kid at home
Sports, lessons, food. Cash flow parents forget to count.
Borrow only the delta
Federal Direct, then private loans
If a gap remains, borrow last and deliberately.
Two moves inside that order are worth calling out.

First, the 529 is your anchor, and it's more flexible than most parents realize. We've written before about using 529 plans as strategic legacy tools, not just tuition accounts, which matters if you over-funded one or want leftover dollars to keep working.

Second, the point of sequencing is so you're never a forced seller. That's the same logic behind Life Driven Investing (LDI), where we build the portfolio backward from your life and sort every dollar into the Four Liquidity Bands: 0-2 years, 3-5 years, 6-10 years, and 10-plus. Tuition four years out isn't a 10-year risk asset. It's a near-band expense you pre-fund, so a bad market in your kid's junior year doesn't force you to sell retirement money at the worst time.

On loans, Shanna offers one rule of thumb she otherwise dislikes: have the student take the Federal Direct loan in their name freshman year, even if you may not need it. It's a safety net if something changes over four years (jobs end, businesses close), and it starts building the student's credit. If you decide to, you can pay it off later. One nice twist she used with her own son: tie payoff to a GPA target you both agree is fair. Hit it, and she covers the loan. Miss it, and it's on him. Kids learn faster when the incentive is real money.

Run the loan math in real dollars
(the 17-year-old test)

Here's the exercise that changes decisions. Take the amount you'd borrow and translate it into a monthly payment the day your student graduates.
Say a business major borrows $27,000 in Federal Direct loans and lands the average starting salary near $65,000. Walk it through: gross pay, minus taxes, minus the loan payment, equals what's left to live on. Then ask where they want to live. New York City? Price an apartment. Suddenly the big, abstract number becomes a very concrete monthly reality a 17-year-old can hold.
Now scale it to the parents' side. Borrow $25,000 a year and that's $100,000 over four years. Stretch that over 25 years because 10 years of payments felt like too much, and at a 6% interest rate, $100,000 becomes roughly $250,000 for a bachelor's degree. If you're 50 now, you could be writing a $1,500 monthly check at 70, on top of your own retirement plan. Ask the real question: is that doable, and is that the trade you want?
Put in those terms, a lot of "reach" schools start looking a lot less appealing, and a strong school with real merit aid starts looking a lot smarter.

What most people miss

The quiet killer isn't the tuition bill. It's the sentence "they worked so hard, I'll just figure it out." It's an emotional, loving decision, and it can cost you a decade of your own retirement.
Two things most families miss:

1. Timing is everything, and it starts two years early. The federal aid application (FAFSA) uses your prior-prior tax year. By the time you're filling it out, that income is already locked. Get to the planning two years ahead and you have real levers: time a sabbatical, stage a business sale, or schedule a big 401(k) distribution so a spike doesn't land in the year that counts. This is the same window-planning discipline that makes a hybrid retirement, our term for stepping back gradually so work becomes optional, actually work. Miss the window and you're just reacting.

2. More funding availability is not good news. Recent federal legislation capped how much families can borrow from the federal government, and private lenders have moved in to fill the gap with loans up to the full cost of attendance. That sounds helpful. The catch is that when funding is available, parents borrow it, and schools have little reason to lower prices as long as we keep paying. Availability is not affordability.

The families who win treat college like every other major financial decision: decode the real price, fund it in order, borrow only the delta, and protect the retirement they can't get back.

A concrete example

Take a VP earning $650,000 with about $200,000 in unvested RSUs and two kids two years apart. The oldest gets into a private school with a $95,000 sticker. Panic says "we make too much for aid, so we'll just pay or borrow it."
The work says otherwise. The school's net price calculator and a call to financial aid show it competes for strong students with merit money, dropping the real cost meaningfully. High school credits trim a semester. The family funds the rest from a 529 first, redirects the roughly $1,500 a month they no longer spend on the kid at home, and has the student take the Federal Direct loan for skin in the game. What's left is a manageable delta, not a $380,000 hole across two kids, and the retirement date doesn't move. Same school, completely different decision, because they priced reality instead of the sticker.

Key takeaways

- The sticker price (cost of attendance) is a maximum, not your price. Your net price depends on each school's own model.
- Merit aid is not means-tested at many schools, so high earners can still win real discounts.
- Fund in order: shrink the bill, spend earmarked 529 and taxable savings, redirect freed-up cash flow, borrow only the delta.
- Pre-fund near-term tuition so a market drop never forces you to sell retirement assets.
- Start two years early. The FAFSA uses your prior-prior tax year, so income timing matters.

Frequently asked questions

Do high earners even qualify for college financial aid?

Often, yes, just not the kind you expect. Need-based aid may phase out at high incomes, but merit aid (scholarships tied to your student's achievement, not your income) is not means-tested at many schools. The only way to know your number is to run each school's net price calculator and call its financial aid office. At Tailored Wealth, we fold this into the broader plan so an education decision doesn't quietly collide with your equity comp or retirement timeline.

What's the difference between the sticker price and what I'll actually pay?

The sticker price (cost of attendance) is the published maximum. Your net price is what's left after merit and need-based aid, and it varies widely by school because each runs its own pricing model. You can compare real net prices and post-graduation outcomes school by school using the U.S. Department of Education's College Scorecard.

Should I use my Roth or 529 before taking student loans?

Usually you spend earmarked education money first (529, then taxable brokerage), and Roth contributions can be tapped penalty-free if the long-term plan supports it. Borrowing is the last step, for the gap that remains. The right order depends on your tax picture and retirement timeline, which is exactly the kind of sequencing we map out with clients at Tailored Wealth.

How do I pay for my kids' college without sacrificing my own retirement?

Fund your own foundation first, then fund school in sequence, and pre-fund near-term tuition so a market drop never forces you to sell retirement assets. Dan walks through the full framework in How to Secure Your Child's Financial Future (Without Sacrificing Your Own).

When should we start planning, financially?

At least two years before your student applies, because the FAFSA uses your prior-prior tax year. That lead time lets you time income events (a sabbatical, a business sale, a large distribution) so they don't inflate the income that determines aid.

Is an expensive private school ever worth it?

Sometimes. If the major requires an accredited or specialized program, or the school competes hard for your student with merit aid, the math can work. If you're borrowing six figures for a degree you could earn at many schools, it usually doesn't. Price the specific outcome, not the brand.

Who this is for

This is written for corporate executives and senior leaders in their 40s and 50s, with $500,000-plus household income and complex compensation, who have kids heading toward college and a retirement they've worked hard to build. If you're staring at six-figure sticker prices, worried you make too much to get help but not enough for it not to hurt, and quietly telling yourself you'll just figure it out, this is the conversation to have before you sign anything.

Book a Free Wealth Strategy Call

Disclosure

The information provided is for educational and informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice and it should not be relied on as such. It should not be considered a solicitation to buy or an offer to sell a security. It does not take into account any investor's particular investment objectives, strategies, tax status or investment horizon.

No investment strategy or risk management technique can guarantee returns or eliminate risk in any market environment.

All investments include a risk of loss that clients should be prepared to bear. The principal risks of Tailored Wealth’s strategies are disclosed in the publicly available Form ADV Part 2A.

The views expressed in this commentary are subject to change based on market and other conditions. These documents may contain certain statements that may be deemed forward looking statements. Please note that any such statements are not guarantees of any future performance and actual results or developments may differ materially from those projected. Any projections, market outlooks, or estimates are based upon certain assumptions and should not be construed as indicative of actual events that will occur.

Tailored Wealth and its advisors do not provide legal, accounting, or tax advice. Consult your attorney or tax professional.