Answer Box (TL;DR)
TL;DR: In Episode 51, Dan Pascone and Justin Detray break down the behavioral biases that quietly push smart, high-earning professionals into bad investment decisions especially recency bias and anchoring. The core message: markets and headlines are engineered to trigger fast, emotional reactions, but long-term results come from calmer decision-making tied to your plan. If you want clearer thinking in volatile markets, this episode gives you a simple mental framework to slow down, filter noise, and stay disciplined.
Key Takeaways
- Recency bias: We instinctively project recent market performance forward (“it went up three years, so it’ll go up again”). That assumption can lead to overconfidence near peaks and panic near lows.
- Anchoring: Investors fixate on a past price (“it was $35, it’ll go back to $35”). In reality, markets don’t “owe” you a return to an old reference point.
- More information doesn’t mean better decisions: Today’s news cycle encourages fast, impulsive decisions and modern trading tools make acting on emotion effortless.
- Great advising is translation + coaching: The best advisors listen first, reduce jargon, and connect today’s fear to the client’s long-term plan.
- Successful people often overestimate control: Running a business rewards decisive action; investing often punishes reactive moves because “it’s already priced in.”
- Compounding is misunderstood even by wealthy people: Some high earners underspend on joy today because they underestimate how powerful time + compounding can be.
Key Moments
- 00:00–00:58 — Episode setup: why this matters in volatile markets
- 01:39–02:34 — Justin’s background: astrophysics → prop trading → wealth management
- 05:51–07:20 — The two big biases: recency bias and anchoring (with clear examples)
- 07:28–10:07 — Information overload: why more data can create more (worse) decisions
- 10:35–11:46 — How Justin coaches clients: listen first, remove jargon, build narrative clarity
- 18:23–21:33 — What successful people misunderstand: compounding + the illusion of control
- 23:17–24:03 — Favorite quote: “Everyone has a plan until they get punched in the mouth.”
Episode Summary
High earners are often decisive, analytical, and used to controlling outcomes traits that build successful careers. But those same traits can backfire in investing, where the news cycle constantly pushes urgency, certainty, and “action.” In Episode 51, Dan Pascone is joined by Justin Detray (partner at Wealthspire Advisors) to unpack the behavioral biases that quietly drive poor investing choices even for sophisticated professionals.
Justin explains two of the most common traps: recency bias (assuming what happened recently will keep happening) and anchoring (fixating on a past price and expecting a return to it). Dan and Justin then zoom out to the bigger issue: in the information age, investors don’t just have more data they have more triggers. With one tap, anyone can liquidate a portfolio in an emotional moment, bypassing the friction and counsel that used to exist when you had to call a broker.
The solution isn’t a perfect forecast. It’s a better process: slow your thinking, listen to what’s truly driving anxiety, and connect short-term noise back to the long-term plan. The episode also highlights a surprising pattern among successful people: many don’t fully grasp how powerful compounding is over decades, which can lead to “dying with too much money” and delaying meaningful spending, gifting, or charitable impact. The takeaway is future-focused and practical: build discipline, stay humble about prediction, and use your plan as the filter when markets get loud.
Transcript
Dan Pascone (00:00) I’m Dan Pascone, CEO of Tailored Wealth and host of the Making Sense of Your Money podcast… This is episode number 51 and today I’m joined by Justin Detray… to break down the behavioral biases that quietly drive bad investment decisions such as recency bias and anchoring…
Dan Pascone (00:58) All right, Justin, thanks for joining the Making Sense of Your Money podcast…
Justin (01:39) …I studied astrophysics… I became a proprietary trader down on Wall Street in 98… traded for the next 14 years… moved out here to California… switched to wealth management…
Dan Pascone (05:05) …what do you see as far as challenges the typical investor face when it comes to behaviors impacting their finances?
Justin (05:51) …recency bias is a huge one… anchoring bias is another one…
Justin (06:16) Recency bias… humans tend to think what’s happened recently is gonna happen again… Anchoring… Stock ABC was at 35. It’s now at 10. So it has to go back to 35. It doesn’t have to go back to 35…
Dan Pascone (07:20) …How do you feel that [the information age] impacts investors?
Justin (07:28) …there’s so much information… it allows people to make more decisions, not necessarily better decisions… you can just click on your phone and liquidate your portfolio if you want…
Dan Pascone (10:07) …how do you… coach your clients to avoid some of the challenges?
Justin (10:35) …understanding what clients might be feeling… then allowing a client to tell you what’s bothering them… no jargon… breaking down complex ideas into an easily understandable narrative.
Justin (14:55) …my relationship with my wife… showed me how important planning is for lowering anxiety… I read Stocks for the Long Run… compounding growth really works… but it takes time and discipline and controlling behavioral impulses…
Justin (18:23) …a lot of my clients actually don’t understand intuitively what compounding growth does… they may not actually be living today… they probably can [spend more]… also… do gifting, do charitable donations now…
Justin (20:16) …successful clients are used to being able to control outcomes… reacting to the news… the probability is stacked against you… it’s pretty hard to outguess the market…
Justin (23:17) …best quote ever… “everybody’s got a plan till they get punched in the mouth” Mike Tyson.
Justin (27:47) …best way to reach you… [REDACTED: personal contact details removed for privacy]
Dan Pascone (28:35) …You can find our podcast along with our newsletter and our YouTube channel all for free at makingsenseofyourmoney.com and as always, prioritize your version of a rich life.
Resources & Citations
- Behavioral finance foundation: Daniel Kahneman, Thinking, Fast and Slow (for System 1 vs. System 2 decision-making). [SOURCE NEEDED: link to publisher or official reference]
- Long-term equity perspective: Jeremy Siegel, Stocks for the Long Run. [SOURCE NEEDED: link to publisher or official reference]
- Podcast hub: https://www.makingsenseofyourmoney.com/
- Podcast archives: https://yourtailoredwealth.com/podcasts/
- Dan’s YouTube channel: https://www.youtube.com/@DanPascone
FAQs
What is recency bias in investing, and why is it dangerous?
Recency bias is the tendency to assume what happened recently will keep happening. In markets, that can lead to chasing performance after a strong run or panic-selling after a drawdown. A better approach is to anchor decisions to your long-term plan and risk target, not last quarter’s headlines.
What is anchoring bias, and how does it show up with stocks?
Anchoring is fixating on a past reference point like a prior stock price and assuming it “must” return there. But markets don’t have to revisit old prices on your timeline (or ever). A cleaner question is: “If I didn’t own this today, would I buy it now at this price and risk?”
Does having more financial information help investors make better decisions?
Not automatically. The episode argues that information overload often leads to more “fast thinking” decisions (emotional, impulsive) rather than slow, deliberate thinking. With modern trading tools, acting on fear or excitement is frictionless so having a rules-based plan matters more than having another news feed.
How should high earners respond when the media makes markets feel urgent?
Step back and reconnect the fear to your actual time horizon. Most scary headlines don’t change a 10–30 year plan, but they can trigger expensive short-term moves. Use your plan as the filter: if nothing structural changed in your goals, cash-flow, or risk capacity, you usually don’t need a portfolio overhaul.
What do successful professionals commonly misunderstand about money?
Many underestimate the power of compounding over decades and end up delaying meaningful spending, giving, or charitable impact. Another common mismatch is control: business success rewards decisive action, while investing often punishes reactive changes because expectations are already “priced in.” The goal is to control process, not predict the next headline.
Next Steps
Want more episodes like this? Explore the full library and resources at makingsenseofyourmoney.com.
Prefer to browse by topic? Visit the Podcast Archives and pick the conversation that matches the decision you’re facing right now.
Related Internal Links
- Making Sense of Your Money (Content Hub)
- Tailored Wealth Podcast Archives
- Podcast on YouTube
- Tailored Wealth Website